Pony Express Pizza Menu

  1. Overview
  2. Menu
Pony Express Pizza 1
Pony Express Pizza 2
Pony Express Pizza 3

Introducing the menu of Pony Express Pizza, a hidden gem located at 343 3rd St, Henderson, KY. This unclaimed pizza spot is making waves with its extensive array of mouthwatering options. The standout specialty is the All Meat pizza, a carnivore's delight featuring six distinct meats. For a zesty twist, the Taco Pizza combines seasoned meat, a blend of cheeses, and fresh toppings. Vegetarians can indulge in the Vegetable pizza loaded with fresh produce.

Complement your meal with sides like Loaded Cheese Sticks or classic Cheesesticks, and don’t forget to choose from a variety of house-made sauces. From Big Red to Dr. Pepper, drinks are also thoughtfully curated. Recent reviews praise the friendly service and improved menu under new ownership. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a newcomer, Pony Express Pizza promises a delightful pizza experience that is uniquely American.

PLEASERSSPECIALITIES
SANDWICHES
SIDESSAUCES
DRINKS

PLEASERSSPECIALITIES

ALL MEAT

TACO PIZZA

ALL CHEESE

VEGETABLE

BACON CHEESEBURGER

HAWAIIAN

PEPPERONI

SAUSAGE

PHILLY CHEESESTEAK

Stromboli

Ham Cheese

Texas BarBQue

Philly Cheesesteak

SANDWICHES

SIDESSAUCES

Cheese Sauce Cup

Ranch Cup

Garlic Butter Cup

Marinara Cup

Breadsticks

Cheesesticks

Pretzel Sticks W Cheese Sauce

Loaded Cheese Sticks

Big Red

CocaCola

Mountain Dew

CocaCola Zero

Diet CocoCola

Sprite

Diet Mountain Dew

Mellow Yellow

AW

Sunkist

Dr. Pepper

DRINKS